close

The Register Home Page Image Image

* Posts by Charlie Clark

14449 publicly visible posts • joined 16 Apr 2007

Boffins carve up C so code can be converted to Rust

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: “Minimal adjustments”

I think one of the things you're missing is that more and more C code is now being maintained by people who may "understand" the language but didn't grow up with using it for everything and are, therefore, less aware of the many potential pitfalls that have been with C from the start. Compilers have been demonstrably better at creating machine code than people for well over a decade now and it's reasonable to start with a high-level language and rely on a compiler to produce fast but safe code.

Fear of Foxconn reportedly driving possible Nissan, Honda and Mitsubishi merger

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: computers on wheels

I think you're missing an essential economic point: the change in policy to favour larger and more expensive cars also removed the need to drive down unit costs, which had dominated the industry since the 1980s, even through various phases of innovation, which is why Japanese manufacturers expanded so successfully: there were making better cars that were also more affordable.

The tax breaks have allowed manufacturers to add components, particuarly for data collection, without needing to worry about the costs or the utility to the driver. Without the financial incentive, we'd have smaller cars with better safety features.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: computers on wheels

Insurance premiums have been driven by more larger and expensive vehicles but the technology is not the driver. Look at the cost of replacement wheels, etc. The change was driven by the poorly thought out incentives to buy SUVs twenty years ago. A couple of bankruptcies back then would have forced the industry to up its game. Instead we got, and still have, expensive tax breaks so that someone has an SUV to drop the kids off at school 10 minutes walk away.

Charlie Clark Silver badge
Go

Re: computers on wheels

It's interesting that both Nissan and Renault have vehicles with an electric drivetrain powered by an ICE. For manufacturers this means a smaller BOM and, thus, profitable even on smaller models. If I was getting a car, this is what I'd be looking for. Solarthermal production of e-fuels has a much higher potential yield than anything driven by electrolysis.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Not just Foxconn

everywhere except the US and EU

Where else, outside China, has got the necessary charging infrastructure for EVs?

The Japanese economy is fairly protectionist and deals between companies like this have been common for years.

Million GPU clusters, gigawatts of power – the scale of AI defies logic

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: A Mystery to Me

The Silicon Valley playbook requires that you achieve market dominance before you think about making money. As such, the plans are similar to those around Uber a decade ago and, unsurprisingly, investors are on board throwing cash – which might include your or my pension fund – at the problem. And as long as cash is available, either directly from investors, or via the stockmarket, this will remain the cash and divert resources away from potentially more efficient approaches. Access to capital is thus being used as a barrier to entry and making a mockery of the idea of "creative destruction".

There was a good interview yesterday on German radio with one of the people behind NX AI on their non-transformative approach, which is apparently both significantly faster and more efficient that that used in the LLMS, but also the decision to avoid language processing precisely because the market is being crowded out by investors.

Cheat codes for LLM performance: An introduction to speculative decoding

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Hallucinations matter

I think someone may have been testing a model to come up with the bullshit.

SoftBank pledges to pour $100B into US, create 100,000 jobs in Trump's second term

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Hmm.

Oh right. Thanks for the update. And who will we always have been at war with tomorrow?

Charlie Clark Silver badge
Go

Re: Did the $50B happen?

Your name is Reacher Gilt and I claim my five Ankhmorpork Dollars!

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Hmm.

I thought Eurasia had always been our greatest ally?

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Trade deficit?

How about investing in the production of illegal drugs in the US for once? Finally do something useful in West Virginia!

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Did the $50B happen?

He's made some shrewd early investments (and did quite well out of ARM) and some shockers, including WeWork. But it's okay because it's OPM™ (Other people's money).

Europe signs off on €10.6B IRIS² satellite broadband deal

Charlie Clark Silver badge
Stop

There are lots of very successful European tech companies. What there aren't are lots of very large tech companies. Europe's fractured markets means the rules are different but the Brussels effect is real and one of the reasons why, for example, European standards in mobile communications went on to dominate the world, though things have, of course, moved on from then.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Trump doesn't really care if they countries do spend more, he's just using a simple argument ("they don't pay enough") as a stick to get concessions, either on weapons purchasing or market access.

NATO was designed to be dependent upon an American superpower. The whole principle of the dollar- rules-based order is that no other country is able to compete with the US. Oil markets went into a tizzy when Saddam Hussain offered to trade oil in Euros.

Fortunately, Europe is not in a position to provide something like NATO on its own. Not that it can't defend itself, which is another thing, it just can't project power in the same way.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Space thinking at government level is still predicated on expensive launches - and they're no longer expensive

Europe does not yet have guaranteed access to cheap launches, which you need for a "strategic and reliable" communications infrastructure.

Broadcom says VMware is a better money-making machine than it hoped

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: margin up by 70%

They're counting on you not having that choice.

We'll see how things are in a year as more companies approach licence renewal or migration.

Google thinks the grid can't support AI, so it's spending on solar for future datacenters

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Nice in theory but the risk of crowding out remains

The model of paying upfront for the buildout of new capacity is a good idea because it allows cash-rich companies to do something with their cash other than keep it in the bank, buy back shares, pay dividends or get involved in even more risky startups. And any kind of power plant is capital intensive. The idea of dedicated power plants is also good, because it can reduce risk from the grid by not adding to the potential total peak load.

However, the effects can be the same as everyone and their dog seeks to add renewable capacity and compete for scarce resources, usually the technicians required to build and manage the facility, but could also include sites. Some of the recent deals have seen utilities sign deals to guarantee power for certain customers, potentially increasing the risk of blackouts for others. Forcing data centre operators to have their own power supply can help here but not if it means that the utilities are unable to raise the finance for their own plans, or keep the engineers to do the work. So, some kind of agreement with local regulator is essential. But when I look back at the history of US power regulators I'm not very hopeful that regulatory capture won't be one of the first victims.

Firefox ditches Do Not Track because nobody was listening anyway

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Tracking

You can impose sanctions on any business that trades in your jurisdiction and, anyone selling advertisting in your country can be held liable. This is why the EU was so effective with it's "opt-in" approach.

India launches two ESA sun-spotters that will fly in incredibly precise formation

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Neat

Stiff but also telescopic? Nice if you can do it, but probably better to go for something that locks into place and has no ability to move independently so that you have only the main satellite to worry about. That's probably possible using the same kind of origami approach they used for James Webb. But, no matter how stiff the arm is, I'm sure it's still going to have more wobble in it than is acceptable. And, if it's really all about the occlusion, then best do away with the connecting arm and its potential for feedback loops, especially if you add in damping, because this is in space with Newton's first law keen to remind you that it's there all time – resonant vibrating bridges spring to mind – and use a second satellite, which is what they're doing.

Total launch mass is probably the least of their worries.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Neat

Weight? In space?

The weight wouldn't matter, but moving anything at the end of the arm could make keeping the satellite's focus still difficult.

Charlie Clark Silver badge
Thumb Up

Re: Neat - Diffraction

Thanks for confirming with details!

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Neat

Not necessarily depth of field, but the sun is not a point source which is why we get penumbras so the occlusion has to be far enough away and big enough for that.

But I think there are probably other reasons for the arrangement: having any kind moving arm is going to cause problems with alignment as both have constantly got to be adjusted to match each other. But there may be other benefits in being able to orchestrate this kind of synchronised stargazing™.

Doctor Who theme added to national sound archive to honor innovation, longevity

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Ron knew more than he was telling

YMMEV: Liam Gallagher credited being hit on the hammer with unleashing his musical genius…

Open source maintainers are drowning in junk bug reports written by AI

Charlie Clark Silver badge
Stop

Re: the usual state sponsored suspects

Russia and China rarely worry about software piracy so open source isn't used by them to "achieve parity". If it's used, it's used for the reasons it should be: you can play around with it and extend it if you want.

Mr Intel leaving Intel is not a great sign... for Intel

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: IBM, Boeing, Intel...

Too true: sack the engineers and look for ways to manipulate the market to reduce competition. Intel's tick-tock approach was okay, but agreements with manufacturers meant they were able to take their eyes of the competition. And, sadly as with Boeing, et al., investors are all in favour of jam today.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Replicant Gelsinger

And the Intel compiler ensured that they were great at CODECs, which is what most people need. Sadly, and I've no idea quite why, but my Intel-Mac doesn't seem to be able to use hardware acceleration for video calls on Google, Zoom or Teams which means the fan spins up pretty quickly and, if I'm not lucky, the network interface being used dies after about twenty minutes, especially on Teams. Still, this gives me a valid reason not to use the camera.

Elon Musk tops US political donor list with $270M+ for Team Trump

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: This is how America works

US elections have been a combination of state fair and outright bribery for most of the country's history. The state fair bit is the snake oil salesmen do their bit for the voters. The money spent on advertising, etc. and now lotteries is really only the tip of the iceberg and the ticket to the Lobby for the real bribery: legislation, where billions can be spent on a single bill. As a result, while the Democrats may have lost the election, the most important donors have made sure the right people have got their visting card. The, er, House always wins. Okay, it's the Senate that makes the money, but this is the better quip and people like Mike Johnson do have some impressive PACs with some rather shy donors.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Musk won't care: he's already made more than enough money on the deal and NASA has no real alternative for launches and the DoD is busy signing contracts for Starlink.

Arianespace's Vega C delayed after gantry throws a tantrum

Charlie Clark Silver badge

It did get rescheduled for later in the same day.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

The launch was successful

https://www.esa.int/Applications/Observing_the_Earth/Copernicus/Sentinel-1/Double_win_for_Europe_Sentinel-1C_and_Vega-C_take_to_the_skies

Having Vega working takes some of the pressure off Ariane while it works on fixing Ariane 6.

Europe's Vega C rocket cleared for launch tonight, first since 2022

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Like I said, are other countries that much different? Yes, we all know about SpaceX, but SES seems to be following the same tried and trusted path that was established in the 1960s.

And ESA and NASA have a lot in common down to the politics, funding and the awarding of contracts. It's a miracle that anything gets built at all, and yet they stilll manage to get some very good stuff done. I'm not deeply au fait with the details but I seem to remember that it was about 10 years ago that it all went to hell in ESA and lots of projects went into stasis or were asked for very expensive overhauls.

You can knock Ariane but, for a while, it held the most impressive record in reliability. Going forward, they will have to embrace both faster innovation and more private enterprise and cooperation with other agencies. I won't be holding my breath for great achievements, but I think things will improve.

Charlie Clark Silver badge
Stop

And in which country is it signficantly different? Pretty much every country considers space of "national" importance, is prepared to throw money at it and add riders that ensure priority for military use.

Besides, ESA and Arianespace are related but not the same and Arianespace can be credited with developing international commercial launches.

Oracle's Java price hikes push CIOs to brew new licensing strategies

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Oracle to Postgres migrations have been possible for years – won't always work, of course – but you can get professional support if you're interested. And, of course, since Amazon did the same thing the other year, it's also happy to help.

The process for any reasonably maintained* environment will be the same: check whether particular features are available on the target platform; define performance metrics; see what works automatically (could be most) and what needs to be done. In 2010 this might have been considered risky, but now I think there are plenty of examples showing that it's fairly straightforward and things often work better than before.

* Yes, I know that PoS that was done by cheapr outsourced from contractors a few years ago might be a bit of a challenge.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Why still using Java of any kind?

The Java code was largely replaced by Python because the developers were worried about what Oracle might do. Even though I prefer Python, I don't think this was necessary – it's still in OpenOffice – and it took a lot of resources. Still, that's one of the points of open source to be able to change the implementation details for any reason.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Thick brown envelopes do wonders for gravity…

Trump tariffs transform into bigger threats for Mexico, Canada than China

Charlie Clark Silver badge
FAIL

Re: Don't repeat the Trump lie!

I never claimed there was anything special about the election. That could have been claimed in 2016 when he quite heavily lost the popular vote, but seeing as the it's the electoral college that does the electing, that's merely an observation.

And in your second paragraph you're agreeing with me: the House tends to flip in the mid-terms.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Don't repeat the Trump lie!

And your point is? The House has frequently been lost in the mid-terms, at least this millenium. It's on a knife-edge at the moment and I don't think anyone would be surprised to see it swing in 2026, which might make Johnson's task of herding cats, even harder. Okay, that git Gaetz has gone, but MTG and her friends are still there, along with a few from the suburbs who are probably already looking over their shoulder.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Don't repeat the Trump lie!

Voting for "change" is very different from a ringing endorsement of the other side – see also the UK General Election. Electorates are fickler and vindictive. Sure, Trump even managed to win the popular vote this time, but he's going to have to deliver improvements in the standard of living quickly, not to lose the mid-terms like he did in 2018.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Don't repeat the Trump lie!

They also seem to have short memories and frequent cases of buyer's remorse. I think 2026 favours the Democrats for the Senate anyway and the House usually swings in the mid-terms.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Indeed, and before that the fairly disastrous mercantililism of the mid-19th century, including coin-clipping. If the exploitation of the resources opened up by the railways hadn't saved it, America would probably have gone bankrupt.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

There are already factories all over the world that simply rebadge incoming Chinese wares so that these can be imported by America without tariffs.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Most of the products for which tariffs have been propose are either not replaceable by domestic products or are not price sensitive. In which case, the tariff is just a sales tax.

Brits are scrolling away from X and aren't that interested in AI

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: It's not just Brits...

In which case they're all in deriliction of their duty to inform the public. However, seeing as the integration was probably set up years ago by some PFY who's since "moved on", they don't have any idea how to change it.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

What are they smoking?

For May 2022, Ofcom measured X's adult reach at 26.8 million…

How do they come up with this? Twitter always was a niche service that rose to prominence largely through the combination of celebrities and journalists. I don't know anyone who's been using it seriously for years as other forums are much better suited for the jobs: celebrities have largely moved to Instagram, niche fan clubs have Reddit or similar, which really only leaves the codependency of politicians and journalists, and a couple of companies who failed to get the memo that it was never a good medium for announcements.

Foursquare to close, but Swarm game will live on

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: How did the company manage to last this long?

What do you mean "record your presence"? I can do this with a press of a button on my watch, but all my apps have options to record the current position, eg. car parking space.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

How did the company manage to last this long?

I'm always amazed at how long "businesses" like this manage to survive. Did anyone use it seriously for a sustained period of time? Or was it just those saddos who enjoyed the game?

Ten years under Dr Su: How AMD went from budget Intel alternative to x86 contender

Charlie Clark Silver badge

While it's true that most of Intel's problems were of its own making, we shouldn't ignore the deals it cut with manufacturers to make sure there was Intel Inside™. AMD remain cash-strapped because it was barely keeping its head above water in the fight with Intel.

Going forward, nVidia should be looking over its shoulder at anything that is "nearly" as good, but as uses less power as its main customers all have more than enough cash to build entire data centres using different architectures if total power consumption is siginifcantly lower.

Kill Oracle's 'JavaScript' trademark, Deno asks USPTO

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: For clarification: This is an old SUN Microsystems Trademark from 1995

A more modern one would be "to google". As I said, I'm not sure of US practice here: in the UK Hoover famously lost its case, for both reasons: genericism due to lack of assertion. I think, but could easily br wrong, Scotch Tape and Kleenex have both successfully defended their trademarks. You can normally tell by mentions in TV shows.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: For clarification: This is an old SUN Microsystems Trademark from 1995

There could be problems over whether the old agreements are sufficient defence of the trademark today. I can't remember US jurisprudence on generics, but I think it's less consumer friendly than the UK.

Given the rise of the use of ECMAScript and TypeScript, it might be a good idea for Oracle to settle, before a new name is chosen and Java loses relevance as a result.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

and a normal person might think they are related in some way

US law doesn't have the man on the Clapham omnibus, so this will be down to technicalities such as whether Oracle is asserting the trademark sufficiently to warrant its protection.